Critique Of Marquis s Argument Against Abortion - 1438 Words

A Critique of Marquis’s Argument Against Abortion Alice Lee Word Count: 1392 In Marquis’s Why Abortion is Immoral, Marquis presents his argument against abortion. The basic idea behind the argument is that, abortion is seriously morally wrong because it is the act of killing a human being with the right to live life. Additionally, abortion is seriously morally wrong in Marquis’s claim because it deprives a being of its future – a future that has the potential to be as worthy and as great as that of an human being – while he explains that the wrongfulness of murdering a fetus is superior to any excuse with a few exceptions. My aim in this paper is to show that the argument fails. In section I, I present the argument and explain the motive, reasoning, and purpose behind the various premises of Marquis. In section II, I present my further evaluation and critique of Marquis’s argument. Lastly, in section III, I will address the several objections that may be brought upon against my thoughts and criticisms. I. Marquis’s Argument In presentation of Marquis’s Argument: â€Å"Abortion, except perhaps in rare instances, is seriously wrong [and] all humans, whatever their race, gender, religion or age, have the right to life.† (Marquis, 754-756). A more detailed version can be outlined as follows: (B1) The unborn are beings with â€Å"futures like ours.† (FLOs) (B2) It is morally impermissible to end the life of something with a future like ours. (B3) So, having an abortion isShow MoreRelatedThe Is An Immoral Act1640 Words   |  7 PagesThomson and Don Marquis wrote two of the most influential articles about it. Thomson wote† A defense of abortiona† and Marquis wrote:†Why Abortion Is Immoral†..an importante issue is ‘Unwanted Pragnency† . In a family where everyone is working full time, another baby is not an option so the mother decides to terminate the pregnancy.. Is this choice morall or immoral.? Marquis argues that a fetus is considered a human from the moment of conservation. If the mother performs the abortion, then she isRead MoreSummary and Critique of Don Maquis- Anti-Abortion Argument2015 Words   |  9 PagesSummary and Critique of Don Maquis- Anti-Abortion Argument The key element of Don Marquis argument is in the effort to distinguish the difference between abortion and contraception in order to provide a clear argument against abortion, aside from extreme cases. Without conflicting with the interest of the general public by being forced to suggest contraception is ethically wrong as well. When he compiles his argument he begins by providing the argument for a ‘pro-choice’ approach which makes theRead MoreA Philosophical Analysis Of Assisted Suicide Essay1518 Words   |  7 Pagesvoluntarily ending one s life has always been a topic of much debate. This essay will be split into two joint parts. Firstly, I will identify and analyze two major ethical issues of the death with dignity debate, while looking at the contrasting viewpoints of Aristotle and Immanuel Kant. Secondly, I will reflect and critique on the issue of assisted suicide from a fairly personal standpoint. I. Analyzing the Death with Dignity Debate There are many different major ethical arguments that might be intertwinedRead MoreA Modern Controversy: the Case of George Tiller Essay8892 Words   |  36 Pageswomen in need of help. For two decades, Dr Tiller spent his life looking over his shoulder. He had become a lightning rod for anti-abortion activists and in 1993 survived an attempt on his life. He rarely talked about his work for fear of attacks against himself or his family. Dr Tillers clinic was one of three in the US that offered what are known as late-term abortions. WHAT IS LATE TERM?Late term mostly centres on the notion of the viability of the foetus - this is widely interpreted as when